There was a decent turnout in the comment section for this one, with names I’ve actually never heard of and may need to try. Check out the winners and vote for which won you think holds (heh) up best.
L’Oreal Paris Elnett Satin Hairspray
Elnett by Loreal Paris. Drugstore brand. Brushable. Holds. In 4 varieties & a cute little travel size. Also looks pretty on your dressing table :) - ...NowGoGetYaMuthafukinShinebox
Big Sexy Hair Spray & Play (and occasionally the Spray & Play Harder). I’ve tried so many hair sprays over the years and BSH is hands down the best: it holds, it doesn’t stink, it isn’t crunchy, and it lasts. Every time I try something new, I end up mad and going back to buy the BSH. - Diosabella
Bumble and Bumble Dryspun Finish Spray
I love the Bumble and bumble Dryspun Finish. It’s not technically a hairspray but a texture/hold spray. It works wonderfully on my finer locks and adds a healthy dose of volume and hold without feeling like a helmet. - TheRealNotMoby