If you’ve been on the hunt for a new eyeliner, but hate paying full price, you’re in luck. You can get Tarte’s Maneater Liquid Eyeliner for $12 at Ulta right now. But wait, the perfect smokey eye is often paired with a wing. If you struggle to make your wings match, have no fear; Tarte’s Maneater Self-Sharpening Liner is perfect for cat eyes, and also on sale for $12.